Deeper Commentary
The reference to Babylon as a virgin may be summed up best by the
GNB paraphrase: "You were once like a virgin, a city unconquered, but you
are soft and delicate no longer! You are now a slave!". The idea is that
she is about to be raped and lose her virginity; for Babylon had never
been captured by another power at that point. Lam. 1 has the same figures
used of what the Babylonians did to Jerusalem: virgin daughter Zion has
been widowed and her children taken, the princess has become slave,
mocked and abused with none to help her, "Oh how she sits alone, the city
full of people" (Lam. 1) is Babylon now sitting in the dirt (Is. 47:1),
just as Judah's king and queen had to 'sit' in humiliation, "your
beautiful crown has come down" (Jer. 13:18) etc. "You
shall no more be called tender and delicate"
uses the words of Dt. 28:54,56 about the judgments upon unfaithful Israel.
Judah acted like Babylon and therefore received
her judgments, just as the rejected of God's people will be "condemned
with the world". The judgments had been carried out by Babylon
under God's direction, but they were to experience them themselves because
they had not only overstepped the limits, but had not shown Divine pity to
the sinful and condemned. And the essence of that warning comes through to
us.
Isaiah 47:2 Take the millstones, and grind meal; remove your veil, strip
off the train, uncover the leg, pass through the rivers-
This was the lowest work; the son of the
slave woman who grinds at the mill means the lowest person in society (Ex.
11:5). Babylon was to fall suddenly and be plunged down to the lowest
slavery. The suddenness of the fall is stressed later in Is. 47. But the
fall of Babylon to Cyrus and his general Darius didn't quite achieve this.
Isaiah 47:3 Your nakedness shall be uncovered, yes, your shame shall be
seen: I will take vengeance, and will spare no man-
See on :2. This scenario didn't totally
come about when Babylon fell to the Medes. The population wasn't
destroyed, there was very little bloodshed. But the language of Babylon's
judgment here and in :2 is very similar to that of Israel's judgment. The
idea is that what Babylon did to Judah was to be done to them, finally.
This is the theme of Revelation, where the judgments upon Israel are
related to the final judgments upon the beast system which has judged her.
"Will spare no man" is an attempt to translate a very difficult original. GNB "and no one will stop me" is a bit better, but the idea seems to be that Yahweh will accept no intercession to stop His vengeance on Babylon, as the redeemer of His people: “Neither will I suffer man to intercede with me”. Vengeance is His for His beloved family member, and nobody will stop Him being the redeemer. And that has wider implications- nobody can stop Yahweh being a redeemer. In this context, the redemption is about serving vengeance; but His redemption has far wider applications.
The language here is disturbing: of being uncovered and shamed as a man takes vengeance upon the virgin daughter of Babylon. Uncovering or exposure of someone's nakedness is a euphemism for sexual intercourse. This surely suggests rape, the kind of rape performed by victors against the vanquished. But Yahweh appears strongly behind it. We could argue that the language is similar to that of the Lamentations, where these things were done to the daughter of Zion. And the idea would simply be that what Babylon did to Zion was to be done to her- under God's control. Lam. 1 has the same figures used of what the Babylonians did to Jerusalem: virgin daughter Zion has been widowed and her children taken, the princess has become slave, mocked and abused with none to help her, "Oh how she sits alone, the city full of people" (Lam. 1) is Babylon now sitting in the dirt (Is. 47:1), just as Judah's king and queen had to 'sit' in humiliation, "your beautiful crown has come down" (Jer. 13:18) etc.
Isaiah 47:4 Our Redeemer, Yahweh of Armies is His name, is the Holy One of
Israel-
Here we have a voice breaking in, as so often in Isaiah, notably in Is. 40. The voice is that of the exiles. And then the prophecy returns to God speaking directly. The hope was that the exiles would say Yahweh was "our redeemer". This is a fantasy of what God hoped they would say. We find similar fantasy in Hosea, the fantasy of love. And yet it was a redemption refused. God was Israel's "holy one", the unique one, in that He was their saviour: "I am Yahweh your God, the Holy One of Israel your Saviour" (Is. 43:3). See on :15. God's abiding, eternal Name is contrasted with how the names of Babylon are removed- "you shall no more be called [named] 'Tender and delicate'... you shall no more be called [named] 'The mistress of kingdoms'" (:1,5). All names and titles, all personality, will ultimately come to nothing. Only Yahweh's Name will endure, centered as it is around His characteristic of eternally saving man. Only the fruits of the Spirit, the characteristics of the Yahweh Name in us, will abide eternally. Your characteristic of [e.g.] impatience will not endure; but your characteristic of [e.g.] pity for sick animals will endure eternally. This points up the supreme importance of character and personality development. For that alone will eternally endure.
The sad thing is that the redemption of Israel made possible through the fall of Babylon wasn't accepted by them; and they remained in exile, for the most part. As Hosea ‘redeemed’ Gomer in His attempt to force through His fantasy for her (Hos. 3:1), so Yahweh is repeatedly described in Isaiah as Israel’s go’el , redeemer (Is. 41:14; Is. 43:14; Is. 44:6,24; Is. 47:4; Is. 48:17; Is. 49:7,26; Is. 54:5,8). The redeemer could redeem a close relative from slavery or repurchase property lost during hard times (Lev. 25:25,26, 47-55; Ruth 2:20; Ruth 3:9,12). The redeemer was also the avenger of blood (Num. 35:9-28; Josh. 20:3,9). All these ideas were relevant to Yahweh’s relationship to Judah in captivity. But the promised freedom didn’t come- even under Nehemiah, Judah was still a province within the Persian empire. And those who returned complained: “We are slaves this day in the land you gave…” (Neh. 9:36). The wonderful prophecies of freedom and redemption from slavery weren’t realized in practice, because of the selfishness of the more wealthy Jews. And how often is it that the freedom potentially enabled for those redeemed in Christ is in practice denied them by their autocratic and abusive brethren.
LXX "Thy deliverer is the Lord of hosts, the Holy One of Israel is his name" would suggest that Yahweh was ready to deliver Babylon- this therefore could be read as a call for her to repent, which is also in view in Jer. 51:9. This prophecy against Babylon can therefore be read like the prophesied destruction of Nineveh- to appeal for their repentance in the gap between prophecy and fulfilment.
Isaiah 47:5 Sit in silence, and go into darkness, daughter of the
Chaldeans; for you shall no more be called the mistress of kingdoms-
Darkness is the imagery of condemnation.
Isaiah 47:6 I was angry with My people, I profaned My inheritance, and
gave them into your hand: you showed them no mercy; on the aged you have
very heavily laid your yoke-
Nebuchadnezzar was God's servant. Babylon were not condemned for executing
God's judgments upon Judah; but for their subsequent bloodlust and showing
no mercy, and abusing those such as the elderly who were not the primary
objects of the Divine judgment. This abuse of the elderly was particularly
noted by God (Lam. 4:16; 5:12). It was their subsequent pride and
pretending to Yahweh (:7) which were the reasons for judgment falling upon
them.
Isaiah 47:7 You said, ‘I shall be a mistress forever;’ so that you did not
lay these things to your heart, nor did you remember the latter end of it-
This also is the criticism made of Judah
(Mal. 2:2). Babylon was intended to reflect and repent; Jer. 51:9 suggests
Babylon was only judged because she was offered a chance to repent which
she refused. I noted on Is. 46:1 that her fall to the Medes was not
executed with the full extent of the judgments then pronounced upon her;
and maybe that was because some of them did repent.
Isaiah 47:8 Now therefore hear this, you who are given to pleasures, who
sit securely, who say in your heart, ‘I am, and there is none else besides
me; I shall not sit as a widow, neither shall I know the loss of
children:’-
This critique of a woman "given to pleasures" mirrors that of Is. 32:9-13 concerning the women of Judah. Judah and Babylon acted the same way and were judged the same way, hence all the connections between Is. 47 about the daughter of Babylon and Lamentations about the daughter of Zion. The language of destruction by burning as chaff in :14 is exactly that of Zion's destruction (Lam. 1:7, 13; 2:3, 4; 4:11). Their sins, the reason for the judgment, were the same. Just as Babylon trusted in her enchanters, "the great abundance of your enchantments" (:9), so had Judah trusted "the clever enchanter" (Is. 3:3). Judah were no better than Babylon, but Isaiah is full of prophecy that she shall gloriously rise again from her judgment. There is no such message for Babylon. In this we see absolute sovereign grace. For God's people are demonstrated to be no intrinsically better than the world of sinners in which they live. But still God would save them. Babylon would sit as a widow bereft of her children; Zion likewise would suffer both widowhood and the loss of her children (Is. 49:20,21; 51:15-20; 54:4). But as Isaiah's prophecies make clear, she would find her husband [Yahweh] again, and be blessed with multiple and eternal children. The descriptions of this in Is. 57 are a parody of the way Babylon permanently loses these things in Is. 47. For Babylon, there was no such promised restoration. She lost her husband [her king?] and her children [vassal states? Inhabitants?]. With only perpetual desolation promised for her future, never to be rebuilt. Babylon had nobody to save them (:15) whereas repeatedly Yahweh is presented as Israel's saviour- by grace alone (Is. 45:21; 46:2,4).
We bear the Name of Yahweh / Jehovah, by reason of our baptism into it. His Name is declared as His character- merciful, truthful, judging sin, patient etc. (Ex. 34:5-7). He who will be who He will be, manifesting His characteristics as He does so, must have His way in us too. Babylon and Nineveh were condemned for having the attitude that “I am, and there is none beside me” (Is. 47:8; Zeph. 2:15). Their self-perception was a parody on the Name and being of Yahweh: He alone can say “I am, and there is none else” (Is. 43:11; 44:6; 45:6,21) and seek to be who He is. He alone can seek to articulate the characteristics that make up His Name onto the lives of others, and onto the things that comprise His Kingdom. We are not to be who we are; to ‘just be yourself’; to ‘just do it’, as foolish slogans and adverts encourage us. We are here to show forth His mercy, truth, judgment of sin, patient saving of the weak etc., not our own personality. We are, in the very end, Yahweh manifested to this world, through our imitation of the Lord Jesus.
Isaiah 47:9 but these two things shall come to you in a moment in one day,
the loss of children, and widowhood; in their full measure shall they come
on you, in the multitude of your sorceries, and the great abundance of
your enchantments-
It could be argued that because the level of
destruction spoken of here didn't happen to the people and city of Babylon
when the Medes took it, therefore the prophecies apply to the king and
royal family of Babylon, who were slain by Darius the Mede. The queen was
therefore left literally a widow. But even that was but a primary
fulfilment; the final fulfilment would be in the destruction of the
sorceries of latter day Babylon (Rev. 18:23). But even that will only be
because she refuses the invitation to repent of them (Rev. 9:21).
Isaiah 47:10 For you have trusted in your wickedness; you have said, ‘No
one sees me’; your wisdom and your knowledge, it has perverted you, and
you have said in your heart-
"No one sees me" is the attitude of this world. Man lives as if he is not in fact observed by God, as if Yahweh does not in fact see and know all things, reading the thoughts of every man before he even has them in his mind (Ps. 139). Living in the awareness of God's omniscience changes everything.
Isaiah 47:11 Therefore evil will come on you; you won’t know when it
dawns: and mischief will fall on you; you will not be able to put it away:
and desolation shall come on you suddenly, which you don’t know-
This sudden desolation refers only primarily to the sudden fall of Babylon
to Darius as described in Dan. 5. As explained on Is. 46:1, the city and
people of Babylon weren't suddenly destroyed. According to Jer. 51:43,
"Mischief" is literally 'wretchedness'.
Paul in Rom. 7:24 felt “wretched”
(s.w. LXX). The Greek word is elsewhere used about
the feelings of the rejected before God’s judgment (James 5:1; Rev. 3:17),
likewise in the LXX (Is. 47:11; Mic. 2:4; Joel 1:15; Zeph. 1:15). Paul
feels as if he is even now standing before the judgment seat of God, and
is condemned- yet suddenly he rejoices that he is in fact amazingly saved
by Christ. This is the very theme of the earlier sections of Romans- that
we are suddenly declared right, justified, as we stand condemned in the
dock before God. This lends weight to the suggestion that Romans 7 is
indeed autobiographical of Paul, declaring the process of his own
conversion, yet telling the story, as it were, in terms which present him
as personifying every Jew under the Law.
Isaiah 47:12 Stand now with your enchantments, and with the multitude of
your sorceries in which you have laboured from your youth; if so be you
shall be able to profit, if so be you may prevail!-
See on :13. "Laboured" is literally
"wearied", as AV. The way of the flesh is a weariness, both for Babylon
and the unfaithful within Judah (Is. 43:22).
Isaiah 47:13 You are wearied in the multitude of your counsellors: let now
the astrologers, the stargazers, the monthly prognosticators, stand up and
save you from the things that shall come on you-
Isaiah 47:14 Behold, they shall be as stubble; the fire shall burn them;
they shall not deliver themselves from the power of the flame: it shall
not be a coal to warm at, nor a fire to sit before-
The fire would burn so totally that not a
live coal would be left (as in Is. 30:14). This suggests a supernatural
cataclysm bursting upon Babylon, after the pattern of Sodom's destruction
(Is. 13:19). But as explained on :1, this didn't happen when the Medes
took Babylon. The prophecy was reapplied to the final fall of Babylon
described in Revelation. The
image of dry stubble before a spreading fire is used of Judah (Is. 1:31).
The judgments on Babylon and upon Judah are so often identical. The
rejected of God's people will likewise be "condemned with the world", sent
back into the world they had loved to share its judgments.
Isaiah 47:15 Thus shall the things be to you in which you have laboured:
those who have trafficked with you from your youth shall wander each one
to his place; there shall be none to save you- The idea is
that the people from the nations within the Babylonian empire would leave
Babylon and return home- including the Jews. But this didn't happen; see
on Is. 46:1. The Jews were intended to flee Babylon before she fell (Is.
48:20), but they didn't; and so God put another plan into operation,
whereby the fall of Babylon was to lead to all the foreigners there,
including the Jews, thereby being freed to return to their ancestral
homelands. But still the Jews remained, as the book of Esther testifies.
God tried then and tries now, by all means, to bring His chosen people to
His Kingdom. Human resistance to His efforts is tragic. He must have
pleasure in we weak sinners who have at least said "Yes" to His plans.